Introduction
A Non-Compete Agreement, or NCA, is a unilateral agreement between an employer and an employee whereby the latter is prohibited to pursue work or start a business after the termination of employment that competes with their (now former) employer’s business. NCA’s can restrict an employee’s ability to work in a particular geographic area, industry, to contact former customers, or to use skills learned on the job, for a certain duration of time.
The FTC’s Non-Compete Clause Rule
The FTC recently issued a Non Compete Clause Rule, or “Final Rule” imposing a nationwide ban on NCA’s on the grounds that they are an unfair method of competition. FTC Chair Lina M. Khan stated that “Noncompete clauses keep wages low, suppress new ideas, and rob the American economy of dynamism, including from the more than 8,500 new startups that would be created a year once noncompetes are banned.” Indeed, 30 million workers, or nearly one in five Americans, are subject to a non-compete agreement or clause.
Non-compete agreements are defined in the FTC’s recent Non Compete Clause Rule as “a term or condition of employment that prohibits a worker from, penalizes a worker for, or functions to prevent a worker from (1) seeking or accepting work in the United States with a different person where such work would begin after the conclusion of the employment that includes the term or condition; or (2) operating a business in the United States after the conclusion of the employment that includes the term or condition.” The Rule also requires employers to give their employees notice that existing NCA’s are no longer enforceable.
Implications
The rule is retroactive and should be interpreted broadly. It nonetheless does not apply to (1) existing agreements for senior executives, who are workers earning an annual salary of at least $151,164 and who are in a “policy-making position;” and (2) to NCA’s entered into during the sale of a business. Employers will not be retroactively liable for using NCA’s prior to September 4, 2024, the date at which the rule came into effect, but the non-compete agreements become unenforceable after that date. Finally, the rule also generally does not apply to workers of the banking, common carrier or aircraft carrier industries.
Challenges to the FTC’s Rule
The Final Rule has been blocked, however, by a District Court ruling in Ryan LLC v. FTC on August 20, 2024. Judge Ada E. Brown ruled that the FTC had surpassed its authority, and that the Rule could not be enforced nationwide. The FTC has filed an appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on October 18, 2024, a case which is widely expected to eventually go to the Supreme Court – a potential dead end, as SCOTUS has recently released a series of decisions curtailing the power of federal institutions. Interestingly, the Ryan decision comes on the tail of the ATS Tree Services case, where a District Court of the Third Circuit denied on July 23, 2024 a preliminary injunction against the FTC’s Rule, and declared it enforceable.
Where Do Employers and Employees Currently Stand?
Pending the appeal decision, the FTC cannot enforce the Non-Compete Rule against employers. Therefore, the Rule did not become effective from September 4, 2024 onwards. Nonetheless, private parties are already challenging NCA’s by using antitrust rules to seek damages, and sometimes successfully. See Order, Goforth et al v. Transform Holdco LLC et al., No. 23-cv-3167 (W.D. Mo. July 18, 2024), ECF No. 50. The FTC has also expressed that it will pursue case-by-case enforcement action.
The State of Affairs in California
On January 1, 2024, California declared practically all non-compete clauses void, which can now be subject to up to $2500 of penalties, codifying existing case law and strengthening already robust anti-non-compete laws. The state has indeed a long-standing history of banning non-competes or restricting their reach. See Cal. Bus. and Prof. Code §§ 16600, 16601, 16602.5.
Following the amendments, it is immaterial whether the non-compete agreement was signed in another state. All employees hired after January 1, 2022, must be notified by their employer that their non-compete agreements are unenforceable.
It is also unlawful to fire an employee for refusing to sign a non-compete agreement. Such an action would amount to wrongful termination.
The narrow exceptions include the sale of a business or the ownership interest in a business, as well as the dissolution of or disassociation from a partnership or LLC.Need assistance?